Visions of Power: Imagining Medieval Japanese Buddhism(2)
时间:2008-01-23 12:08来源:The Journal of Religion,Vol.78作者:Reviewed… 点击:
beliefs are rendered into images" (p. 3) that mediates, among other
things, "form and formlessness" (p. 281). The products of this
medieval imaginaire--icons, myths, local deities, relics, and much
more--are the very things that Zen ideology calls into question. The
premise of this volume (and in various fashions of all Faure's work)
is that this imaginaire was from the very beginning as present in
Zen as were discourses on emptiness and enlightenment. Its presence
in Keizan's universe, therefore, cannot be attributed solely to
popularizing and esoteric syncretism. In his own way, Faure must
once again struggle as mightily as any Mahayana thinker ever did
with the "two truths"--although in a modern idiom of enormous
erudition--in order to show us how a man whose religious ideology
rejected all imagination could describe himself as having been a
tree-deity "with the head of a dog, the body of a kite, and the
belly and tail of a serpent" (p. 30).
The genres of Keizan's imaginaire, furthermore, are not his, but
extend backward and forward in time, so that his text seeks to
homologize its expressions with what he perceives as eternal ones.
In the end, Faure cannot recover Keizan except as an intersection of
East Asian thoughts and images at a particular moment and place. He,
too, must move forward and backward in time, from China to Japan and
back, away from and toward Keizan. It is this last movement that
impresses most and distinguishes this book from Faure's previous
work. Here we have an intellectual biography that does not so much
place an individual in history as find a history in an individual.
Finally, Faure's use of Le Goff's terms suggests the possibility of
mutually illuminating comparisons with parallel studies of medieval
Europe. Faure, along with others such as Carl Bielefeldt and William
Bodiford, has reconstructed the study of Zen as a religion to the
point that scholars of religion generally should begin turning to
this field to find what they would not expect: a rich tradition of
icons, rituals, myths, and magical power. This volume is the best
place for them to start.