Anyone who didn't spend this spring in a severely media-deprived
locale--an Antarctic substation, say, or the lazily pinwheeling
Russian spacelab--has probably heard the news: Rene Descartes, the
17th-century mathematician who shaped the world as we know it, has
been officially pronounced dead.
The eulogy was delivered by Bill Moyers, public television's own
Piers Ploughman, via his phenomenally successful TV series and
book-cum-transcript, Healing and the Mind. But in truth, the old
philosophe's stiff--which had lain for three centuries in the halls
of medicine like some glass-entombed Lenin--had become a bit of an
embarrassment.
Immortalized in Bartlett's for his inscrutable, Popeye-like
declamation, "I think therefore I am," Descartes was history's most
persuasive partisan of the mind-body split, a bedrock notion of
modern science. Mental events, the savant declared, occur in a
separate domain from those of the flesh. Consciousness has no
business in the mean streets of matter. As a result, medical science
came to be dominated by a materialism so iron-clad that one
19th-century theorist felt emboldened to quip that the mind's
influence upon the mechanism of the body was like "the steam-whistle
which accompanies the work of a locomotive engine but cannot
influence its machinery."
The problem with this is obvious to anyone who ever had an unseemly
thought about their junior-high English teacher and then blushed:
"The soul's passions," said Aristotle, who had it right all along,
"seem to be linked with a body, as the body undergoes modifications
in their presence."
By 1900, medical science had at least begun to suspect as much.
Freud and Janet's investigations of hysterical paralysis provided a
benchmark of the mind's power over the body. Dr. Walter Cannon
discovered in the 1930s that the central nervous system controlled
many bodily functions and suggested that it in turn was subject to a
regulatory mechanism "which in human beings we call the
personality."
Still, if anyone could be credited with shutting off the
refrigeration on Descartes' mortal remains and letting the aroma of
a paradigm gone bad reach science's stuffed nostrils, it is Candace
Pert, Ph.D., former chief of the Brain Biochemistry Section of the
National Institute of Mental Health and codiscoverer of the brain's
opiate receptors. Subsequent revelations that similar docking sites