P.443
aspects of the Buddha nature. Moral rules are deontological,
prescribing the requital of the Four Graces to which one owes
one's life. Yet the theory of the motivation to do good
contains prudential reasons that reflect the teleological
ground of Won Buddhism. Thus, the moral system of Won
Buddhism is based on Buddhist teleological grounds, but the
specific moral rules as means to that goal come from
Confucian deontology. It is Won Buddhism's achievement to
have synthesized these two seemingly incompatible moral
tenets into a harmonious whole.
FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY
NOTES
*Wonbulgyo(at), or Won Buddhism, is a form of Mahayana
Buddhism founded by Pak Chung-bin(au), better known by his
style Sot'aesan(f), after great enlightenment in 1916 in
Korea. For a general introduction to Won Buddhism, see my
"What is Won Buddhism?" Korea Journal 24, no.5 (May 1984):
18-32; my "The Ethics of Won Buddhism: A Conceptual Analysis
of the Moral System of Won Buddhism" (Ph.D. diss., Michigan
Stale University, 1979).
1. Quoted by Roland Robertson in The Sociological
Introduction of Religion (New York: Schocken Books,
1970), p.103. "For example Christianity was historically
composed of elements from Eastern and Near Eastern religi
-ons (e.g. virgin birth, baptism, burial services), from
Greek religions (asceticism, cosmology, escatology), from
Judaism (monotheism) and from gnostic religious doctrines."
2. Terada Toru(av) and Mizuno Yaoko(aw) eds. Dogen(a)
(Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, 1972), p.307. The translation is
mine. For an English translation of Dogen's Shobo-genzo,
see Yuho Yokoi, trans., Zen Master Dogen (New York:
Weatherhill, 1976).
3. So Cheha(ax), ed. Sosan's Son'ga kuigam(ay) [Models from
Ch'an Traditions] (Seoul: Poyon'gak, 1978), p.143, para.
#57.
4. Wing-tsit Chan(az), trans. and ed., A Source Book in
Chinese Philosophy (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University
Press, 1963), p.646, This work is referred to hereafter
in this paper as "Chan, Source Book. "
5. Ludwig Wittgenstein, On Certainty, trans. Denis Paul and
E.E.M. Anschombe and G.H. von Wright (NewYorkand Evanston:
J & J Harper, 1969), p. 81.
P.444
6. Chu Hsi and Lu Tsu-ch'ien,(ba) comp., Reflections on
Things ot Hand, trans., Wing-tsit Chan, (New York:
Columbia University Press, 1967), p. 283. Hereafter refer
-red to as "Chan, Reflections."
7. Loc. cit.
8. Charles Wei-hsun Fu, "Morality or Beyond: The
Neo-Confucian Confrontation with Mahayana Buddhism, "
Philosophy East And West XXIII, 3: 395. PEW hereafter.
9. Ibid., p. 390ff. Fu shows how life-affirming and
this-worldly tenets are strongly suggested in the texts