P.234
Paratantra means ruled by others (parava`sa).... It
is not constructed (akalpita), is born from causes,
and is thoroughly inexpressible (anabhilaapyas
sarvathaa). (Y22)
Further, paratantra is defined as the "pure, worldly
domain" (`suddhalaukikagocara), that is, phenomena
unobscured by ignorance or mental defilements (Y22).
To see reality in this way is not to lose sight of
the particularities, for example, the separate eyes
in the tail of a peacock. It is simply to see their
connectedness, to see that no one thing has
independent (svabhaava) existence.
Unlike Yogaacaara, James was making an original
statement with his vision of a pluralistic universe,
He devotes at least half of A Pluralistic Universe
to refuting what he calls the "absolutistic monism"
of Bradley, Spinoza, and Emerson, because they make
an abstract "whole" prior to the experienced parts.
He also rejects theories that disjoin phenomena
totally in order to provide an alternative to
monism. James argues for an abandonment of these two
extremes on the ground that they have no empirical
basis:
Neither abstract oneness nor abstract independence
exists; only real concrete things exist.(46)
In keeping with his empirical orientation, he argues
first for a move away from the purely abstract back
to the realm of experience, wherein things are
indeed experienced as continuous and as entering
into various relations with one another. The
ontological implications of these experienced
continuities and relations should be taken into
account, he says, "in a world where experience and
reality come to the same thing."(47) In the case of
any A and B, the very fact that they can enter into
relation shows, for James, that they are not
entirely distinct, "not separated by a void," not
mutually impenetrable or irrelevant; rather, they
are co-implicated and "must have an inborn mutual
reference each to each."(48)
For James, the mutual relatedness of phenomena
does not cancel out their separateness, however
mutually exclusive the logical categories of unity
and disunity, oneness and manyness, may seem to be:
"In life distinct things can and do commune together