Where text meets flesh: burning the body as an apocryphal pr(10)
时间:2008-01-23 10:54来源:History of Religions,Vol.37 No作者:James A.… 点击:
out of compassion one burns the head and vows to cultivate the four
dhyanas and samadhi and to uphold the dharma. This has now been
established.(39)
The significance of this passage, beyond its explicit explanation of
when and why monks' heads were to be burned, lies in the fact that
Vinaya monasteries in late imperial China were responsible for
training monks to give ordinations. It is highly likely, then, that
these instructions applied not to one particular institution but to
many, perhaps even to all ordinations performed in China at this
time. It is hard to be sure if this is true, since an extensive
search of other monastic gazetteers; has failed to turn up anything
similar. This does not mean that the monastery in Wulin was unusual,
but rather that the gazetteer itself is unusual in that it devotes
any attention at all to living monks. Most so-called monastic
gazetteers were in fact literary-cum-topographical guidebooks rather
than records of mundane Buddhist activities.(40)
The Fanwang jing contains precepts but does not contain instructions
on how to administer those precepts. Moreover, the sixteenth minor
precept does not say anything about vows, burning the head, or
burning incense on the body. Clearly, the model for ordination
burning is drawn from the Fanwang jing and the Shouleng'yan jing
used in conjunction. We can very easily confirm that the two
passages were so linked by looking at commentaries on the Fanwang
jing. The Fanwang jing pusa fie zhu by the Song monk Huiyin (dates
unknown) cites the Shouleng'yan jing in support of the sixteenth
minor precept of the Fanwang jing, as does the Fanwang jing pusa fie
lueshu by Hongzan (1611-85).(41) However, neither of these texts
makes any mention of burning at ordination as such.
One theory that might be advanced is that the passage from the
Shouleng'yan jing was composed in the early eighth century in order
to validate some preexisting ordination practice based on the
Fanwang jing. This is certainly a reasonable supposition, but one
that is not borne out by the textual evidence. Although we have
evidence that people burned or branded their heads in the centuries
after the composition of the Shouleng'yan jing, it was never
explicitly linked to ordination, nor to the bodhisattva precepts.
In his infamous Memorial on the Buddha Relic (Lun fo gu biao) of
819, Han Yu (768-824) complained to the emperor that if he should
honor the Buddha's relic, the people, being easily misled, would "in